this post was submitted on 11 Apr 2025
1260 points (97.9% liked)
Lemmy.World Announcements
30111 readers
56 users here now
This Community is intended for posts about the Lemmy.world server by the admins.
Follow us for server news π
Outages π₯
https://status.lemmy.world/
For support with issues at Lemmy.world, go to the Lemmy.world Support community.
Support e-mail
Any support requests are best sent to info@lemmy.world e-mail.
Report contact
- DM https://lemmy.world/u/lwreport
- Email report@lemmy.world (PGP Supported)
Donations π
If you would like to make a donation to support the cost of running this platform, please do so at the following donation URLs.
If you can, please use / switch to Ko-Fi, it has the lowest fees for us
Join the team
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Sorry if this isn't the right place to ask, but are you able to confirm whether admins have reported this to the police?
Even if violence hasn't been perpetrated, the harassment is still a crime surely.
I don't know if others have, I only know that we (Lemmy.World, Fedihosting Foundation) have not reported it to the police.
I don't have high hopes that the police would be able to do anything about this. For the harassment against the person shown in the images, that would likely have to be reported by them directly for the police to take that up.
For random online spam, as in harassment of fediverse users receiving the PMs, that seems like it would be an extremely low priority for police. It's also likely fairly difficult to impossible to follow up on, considering that the person sending the PMs most likely used a VPN to access these accounts.
Hmm.
The people receiving the spam are not being harassed, obviously.
The woman depicted is very likely the target of harassment.
Sharing the images depicting violence is tantamount to a threat of violence.
As admins, you're not just witnesses but the stewards of a community and the representatives of many thousands of people in this matter.
Pre-empting what the police will do is not a reason not to report. You don't know what they will do. They might do nothing at you would have wasted 15 minutes. On the other hand perhaps Nicole has been trying to get a restraining order against some creep but has been unable to due to lack of evidence.
I have spam in my email. Should I report that to the police as well?
There just isn't enough for regular police to go on, without even considering jurisdiction. Cooperating with authorities is fine, but there's not really anyone to proactively reach out to about this.
Yes. If you run an email server and one of the accounts has been used to perpetrate a harassment campaign including threats of violence then obviously you should report that.
Agreed, but there is no proof of this. We also don't know their true identity to check with them directly.
The images did not depict violence directly, it was a gory image of a dead person. They were very likely sent by a copycat not involved in the original harassment campaign and intended to fuck up fediverse users more than anything else. They did not appear to imply any kind of threat.
This would require a lot more than 15 minutes to file a proper report. First we have to collect all relevant information that we have available and compile them in a format that can be submitted. Once we have this information we have to identify a police department to report this to. We are legally based in NL, as that's where our non-profit Fedihosting Foundation is located. I'm based in Germany, so it would also be an option to report it here. The depicted person is claimed to be in Canada, so maybe this should be reported to a police department over there. Or maybe to all of them.
All of this would easily add up to 2 hours or more if you want to do it properly and not just look for 3 online forms to write "hey there is someone sending spam".
If this was a paid job and I was doing this during working hours I wouldn't mind, but all the time I spend here is taken out of my personal time, the same as with anyone else on our team, and also the same you'll see with most other fediverse instances.
If we receive a request for information from (real) law enforcement we'll be more than happy to provide relevant data, but doing this for the (perceived low) chance of that somehow being linked from a random police report is a fairly high time investment as described above.
I have compiled what I think to be almost all of the piblic information about this case. If you do need something please PM me.
Tell you what: log the time it takes, and I will personally pay you $60/hour for your time to make a proper report.
And no, Iβm not being sarcastic.
No need, this info isn't hard to compile, only took a few hours. If anyone does intend to take this to law enforcement, please PM me as I have compiled what I think to be almost all of the public information available about this case.
Respectfully, I don't share your assessment of the seriousness of the crime. You seem to be weighing the question of whether someone has been harassed or intimidated from the perspective of a "reasonable third party". However, I suspect that the law assigns considerable weight to the question of whether the victim feels intimidated or harassed. For example, you're correct that sharing the gore image is not a direct threat of violence, however I feel certain that the woman depicted in the earlier images taken from the live stream would feel concerned for their safety.
I would also like to clarify one aspect of which you may not be aware. It's very easy to confirm the woman's place of work beyond any reasonable doubt, with images she has posted to other platforms.
I understand that it's unreasonable to say that you specifically or any admins of lemmy.world or any other instance should give up hours of your free time to make a police report.
However, as others in this thread have suggested this incident underlines the limited protections lemmy has against this type of attack and it seems likely that we will see a lot more.
I also respectfully disagree regarding the likelihood that reporting this crime could be useful. It's not a question of "somehow being linked from a random police report". If the victim ever does contact the police, which seems very likely to me, it's extraordinarily likely that a report from lemmy would be identified as being related.
It's not my intention to berate you personally over this, and as I mentioned above I acknowledge that it's unreasonable to expect you personally to take action in this specific case. I am however concerned that Lemmy's federated nature is not well suited to addressing this type of risk to members of our community.
Agreed. At least here in the US, you'd have more chance of winning the lottery than getting a cop to care about this issue without the person directly involved reporting it. And even then it would be a crapshoot.
The right cop will care about it, but the right cop doesn't work for your city and so you don't have any way to contact them.
Anyone asking you to file a report with police has likely never had to file a police report. They don't even want to file reports for things that actually happened directly to you, if they can convince you out of it lol.
Iβm not a fan of LEO, BUT at the same time doing nothing should not be an option. What I mean by that is that Johnny Law should still be contacted and a report filed (at the very least). Even if they do not follow up on it, thatβs on them and not us (the fediverse).
see https://lemmy.world/post/28077771/16383824
Would it even be realistic to know the right place to report it to? Just because the messages say Toronto doesnβt necessarily mean the victim is in Toronto, and reporting it to the wrong place at most probably just means wasting resources in one location and coming no closer to stopping the harassment. Is there anything from a national group like the RCMP, FBI, or INTERPOL to help in a case like this?
There's a video of her eating food in the shopping centre where whe works. You can find it on google Street view.
Haha what fantasy land do you live in where that helps anything?
Actually smartass, it's called Australia. We have laws specifically to address this exact situation. I have made police reports in my time, and can assure you that the police would take a campaign of this scale very seriously.